Old Mill Restaurant

5031 New Harmony Rd, Evansville, Indiana 47720 USA

Reasonable

Closed Now

Opens Sun 11a

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

Since 1936 our "Old World" decor and excellent cuisine have been the cornerstone of fame for the Old Mill. We are proud to serve all of the Evansville metro area including Kentucky and Illinois.

Reviewed by
Mickey R.

October 31, 2012

Seafood buffet on Friday nights. Had my first "fiddler" here (it's basically a whole fried catfish). I'm not a huge fan of catfish, but this was pretty awesome. Their award banners for "best... Read more

Reviewed by
Maddy B.

May 09, 2023

Rude on the phone, Used to love this place as a kid. I had a couple questions and the lady on the phone let me know very rudely that "We are closed and on vacation" Do you guys still have your... Read more

Reviewed by
Michael L.

December 21, 2018

So my work got old mill catered last night for Christmas dinner it was absolutely disgusting the type of restaurant you would catch on an episode of kitchen nightmares. So biscuits were... Read more

View 13 reviews on