July 11, 2020
Was a great spot, changed hands a few times and then closed permanently in 2018. We live 2 miles down the road and know the former owners. The closest full-service restaurant west is Hedges on 9-mile point which is an iconic Webster/Rochester spot for families, celebrations, wedding receptions, etc. It’s solid but not stellar. To the east of Pultneyville is Bay Street Hotel (not a Hotel fyi) which has a fun local bar and a restaurant dining room in the back that was really exceptional for decades and though a new owner and chef, is still solid. There are a handful of great lunch spots in/near Pville itself— Embark Ciderworks (French fries are great) and also Burnap’s Farm Market 15 min east towards Sodus.
Was this helpful?