A trip to Sanibel isn't complete without a visit to Pinnochio's. Favorite of the kids and adults alike. Not cheap (it's a resort town, after all) but they give generous servings and the ice cream is delicious.
A good value, though.
Pleasant but tired property. Probably best available on the island.
Warm. Welcoming. Outstanding food. Kid friendly. Friendly staff. Owner took the time to greet us and tell "dad jokes" to our kids. A little diversion from 95 but well worth it.
Pleasant and helpful staff helped to make a disappointing property bearable. Room smelled of smoke.
Outstanding... laid back, comfortable, old Florida style resort composed of privately owned condominiums. I'm a condo owner, so I'm biased... but it is widely regarded as one of the best - if not the best - place to stay on Sanibel Island.