Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop

727 Manhattan Ave, New York, New York 11222 USA

1,672 Reviews

View Photos

Budget

Closed Now

Opens Fri 4:30a

Independent
Credit Cards
not Accepted
Wheelchair
Accessible

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“Donuts that will Keep You in Neverland!”

A retro bakeshop with swivel stools, Peter Pan serves coffee and a vast array of handmade doughnuts, from sour cream to coconut cream. In summer, customers can design an ice cream sandwich with doughnut halves in place of the traditional cookies. One favorite combo: a red velvet doughnut with strawberry ice cream.

Reviewed by
Martha K.

August 24, 2024

Stumbled upon Peter Pan Donuts during the weekend and I for sure have to stay I do not regret it! The donuts were visibly appealing and priced reasonably. We got the blueberry buttermilk donut... Read more

Reviewed by
Peter C.

July 31, 2024

I tried a total of 3 donuts here on a Sunday morning and I'd recommend arriving early since a line started forming out the door by 11am. The glazed cruller was a light and fluffy yeast donut... Read more

Reviewed by
Michael C.

July 21, 2024

Finally came to this Brooklyn staple!! Overall pretty good! I liked the blueberry buttermilk cake donut a lot, but thought the glazed donut was decent but nothing special! Maybe that's my choice... Read more

View 1,672 reviews on