Little Pie Company

424 W 43rd St, New York, New York 10036 USA

822 Reviews

View Photos

Reasonable

Closed Now

Opens Fri 8a

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
Outdoor
Seating

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“mouth watering magic pies”

the Little Pie Company where mouth-watering magic is worked over regional recipes from mom’s kitchen, straight out of the oven, straight from the heart. Each delicious dessert is created from scratch (no mixes), using only the finest, purest, freshest ingredients (nothing artificial, nothing chemical). Little wonder that since 1985, people from all over the world have been sniffing out the comforting, simple pleasures wafting from the ovens of the Little Pie Company, a friendly oasis of warm country goodness in the heart of Manhattan.

Reviewed by
Dana L.

March 17, 2024

We picked up two key lime pies for a birthday celebration. I'm not a huge key lime person but this pie was delicious! The filling was smooth, tart, and fragrant and the graham crust was sweet and... Read more

Reviewed by
Ken G.

March 06, 2024

This place did not disappoint! The Mississippi Mud Pie was phenomenal! This is a chocolate on chocolate on chocolate pie that's delicious. Each bite is decadent and chocolatey. The textures are... Read more

Reviewed by
Edward M.

March 01, 2024

In a last-minute scramble for a dessert for a dinner party, Little Pie Company was my immediate thought. Their sour cream apple walnut pie had won me over in the past, so I was excited to find... Read more

View 822 reviews on