Martindale Chief Diner

1000 State Route 23, Craryville, New York 12521 USA

104 Reviews

View Photos

Reasonable

Open Now

Thu 7a-8:30p

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
No Wifi

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“Delicious sandwiches & milkshakes in Craryville, NY”

Cute little diner. When you stop at Martindales Chief Diner, you'll find yourself eating inside a retro diner with a throwback offering of breakfast and lunch specials. From the delicious meatloaf to the fluffy omelettes, you're sure to enjoy a meal combined with the great service Martindales Chief Diner provides. Local favorites include the BLT, fish and chips, and our 3-layer Lemon Cake. Find your new favorite meal at Martindales Chief Diner the next time you're in town, in Craryville, New York!

Reviewed by
D Patrick G.

February 19, 2024

I love this place if you like and miss the restaurants of yesteryear you can relive those memories here the food is amazing and the prices are spot on Read more

Reviewed by
Mike C.

August 22, 2023

Love almost everything about this place except the dated, problematic name and sign! This is an authentic chrome diner manufactured in the late 50s and lovingly maintained. You can see they've... Read more

Reviewed by
Gregory C.

August 07, 2023

Back in my good graces. Our utensils were clean this year. Woo Hoo !!! Stopped in on Sunday just before noon. They were busy, but we got a table for four almost immediately. Thank goodness we... Read more

View 104 reviews on