NYC Pizza

4775 S Harvard Ave, Tulsa, Oklahoma 74135 USA

136 Reviews

View Photos

Budget

Closed Now

Opens Thu 11a

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
Outdoor
Seating
No Wifi

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“we make everything by hand”

Our recipe hasn’t changed over the years, but what has changed is who holds the pizza cutter. Kenneth Lehman, JR. is proud to continue the tradition of bringing Authentic New York Pizza from his family to yours. Over the years, people have asked us why our pizza is more expensive than chain/franchise pizzerias. We can only say quality comes at a price. At NYC Pizza, we make EVERYTHING BY HAND. We make our pizza and marinara sauce daily from scratch. Our pizza dough is made fresh each and every day...sometimes twice a day. We use ONLY whole milk mozarella cheese and the freshest ingredients we can buy from our distributors. Does this cost more? Sure it does; but it's what we choose to do in order to prepare what many Tulsans have come to believe is the best pizza in Tulsa.

Reviewed by
Martyn B.

December 18, 2023

What a great find! New to Tulsa and was on the hunt for a New York style pizza! Bingo! Slices to go, great tasting and authentic pizza! Read more

Reviewed by
Tuan P.

August 04, 2023

I have tried almost everything at NYC Pizza, except the desserts and salad. The only dessert I've tried is the tiramisu which was alright, but these items are not why you go to NYC Pizza. One... Read more

Reviewed by
Richard R.

March 22, 2024

Food is really good. It's the kind of place where when you fold your pizza to eat orange goodness runs down your arm. Service is so so. No decore you will probably want to carry out. Read more

View 136 reviews on