Remove Ads

Tuck Shop

75 N Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, New York 11964 USA

25 Reviews
$$
Reasonable
Open Now
Thu 10:30a-10:30p
  • Independent
  • Credit Cards
    not Accepted
  • No Wifi
Add to Trip
Remove Ads

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

Family-owned local ice cream shop on Shelter Island, NY that's been in business for over 30+ years! Open all summer long!! CASH ONLY!

Read More >
Photo of Nicole S.

Reviewed by
Nicole S.

Fun local ice cream shop on Shelter Island. Pretty sure there aren't many options to choose from (especially open after 8pm or so). There was a decent but quick-moving line and a little wait. The... Read more

Photo of christine m.

Reviewed by
christine m.

Ice cream at this Shelter Island spot was mediocre and overpriced. For better service and a true "homemade ice cream experience," head to Whales Tale instead. Unfortunately, rude teenagers... Read more

Photo of NV R.

Reviewed by
NV R.

So delicious. Clean, fun, kids love it. Megan is #1 Read more

Tuck Shop

75 N Menantic Rd
Shelter Island, New York
11964 USA
Remove Ads

Hours

Open now until 10:30 pm
  • Sun - Fri: 10:30 am - 10:30 pm
  • Sat: 10:30 am - 11:00 pm

Problem with this listing? Let us know.

Has RV parking changed? Let us know.

Remove Ads
  • Check
    Parking
  • Unknown
    Pets Allowed
  • Unknown
    Restrooms
  • Unavailable
    Wifi
  • Unknown
    Wheelchair Accessible
  • Unavailable
    Credit Cards Accepted
Reservations
Does not take
See More Details (12)

Parking, Dining

Remove Ads

Nearby Hotels

Southold, New York
FastBook
$$

Click to discover a
great deal!

Riverhead, New York
East Marion, New York
East Hampton, New York
Southampton, New York
Remove Ads

Related Trip Guides

Remove Ads
4675178