Matthew's Seafood House

935 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, New York 11770 USA

80 Reviews

View Photos

$$$

Pricey

Open Now

Fri 9a-4a

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
Wheelchair
Accessible
Outdoor
Seating
No Wifi

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“a delicious meal and beautiful views”

Make your summer special at Matthew’s Seafood House, located at the east end of Ocean Beach, Fire Island. Matthew’s has been a family owned and operated establishment since 1974. Always glad to be your host for a delicious meal and beautiful views from our waterfront deck and bar. You can find us on the Great South Bay, just off of Buoy #15.Visit our Matthew’s Market, where we sell the freshest seafood on the island. We specialize in prepared foods, salads, party platters and even giftware for the home!

Reviewed by
Ilaria S.

August 06, 2023

I had an incredibly disappointing experience at this restaurant. The service was unbearably slow, and we waited a frustrating 40 minutes just to get our drinks. When we finally placed our food... Read more

Reviewed by
Amber E.

July 28, 2023

Can't beat the location - right on the dock with a shady, breezy patio. They have some sort of event every night. We went Wednesday for wine specials, tapas and some great live music by Dennis &... Read more

Reviewed by
stu c.

September 09, 2023

A great surprise. We had a few meals while in town, this was the top. Friendly service (J P), great view and such a relief to finally get some good steamers. Actually ordered steamers at two... Read more

View 80 reviews on