US
Michigan
Mackinac Island

Original Murdick's Fudge of Mackinac Island

7363 Main St, Mackinac Island, Michigan 49757 USA

67 Reviews

View Photos

Reasonable

Open Now

Fri 8a-10p

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
Wheelchair
Accessible

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“traditional fudge!”

Mackinac Island's only Original Fudge Maker since 1887. All-natural, gluten-free Pure Michigan deliciousness.The company still follows Sara Murdick’s recipe and the old-fashioned fudge-making techniques that have been passed down through the generations. Original Murdick’s Fudge has expanded to other locations on Mackinac Island as well as in Mackinaw City and St. Ignace, Michigan, in addition to three stores and a bakery in Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts. Bob Benser, Sr. and Bob Benser, Jr. continue that tradition today along with the entire Benser family.

Reviewed by
Tiffany H.

December 05, 2021

Tried various fudges on Mackinac Island and Murdick's was our favorite! I mean they had the classics AND some really fun seasonal adds like PUMPKIN SPICE. The basic in me could NOT resist. The... Read more

Reviewed by
Theresa S.

September 26, 2023

First time on the island. We took a right on Main Street and came across Murdick's so my husband went in. We wanted fudge with peanuts, but they didn't have any. At first I thought maybe because... Read more

Reviewed by
Jessica O.

May 09, 2023

I was really in the mood to buy some fudge when I walked in to Murdick's. They had out samples of their maple flavored fudge. I tried this flavor but I did not like it, but I do not like maple... Read more

View 67 reviews on