Lake Hiawatha Dairy

79 N Beverwyck Rd, Lake Hiawatha, New Jersey 07034 USA

67 Reviews

View Photos

$$$$

Budget

Closed Now

Opens Fri 11a

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
Not Wheelchair
Accessible
Wifi

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

The Dairy @ Lake Hiawatha has been family owned for over 25 years. We offer homemade ice cream, picture image ice cream cakes for any occasion and a variety of frozen yogurt flavors.

Reviewed by
Brendalynne F.

June 26, 2021

I've only been here once so far. I got a milkshake with Nutella Crunch ice cream, and it was average at best. I liked that the consistency wasn't too thick so I didn't have to sit there for a... Read more

Reviewed by
Dorothy L.

July 14, 2021

Love this little gem in town... their icecream is so so good!! And I can't wait to try more flavor!! They have this 'one way traffic' so the customer won't be running into one another.. they... Read more

Reviewed by
Sarah C.

January 06, 2022

It's winter, but I'm always going to eat ice cream. I needed to try out Lake Hiawatha Dairy after seeing their social media posts and discovering they offer gluten-free cones. I went to the shop... Read more

View 67 reviews on