Silver In the City

434 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana 46204 USA

221 Reviews

View Photos

Reasonable

Closed Now

Opens Thu 10a

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
Pet Friendly
Wheelchair
Accessible

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“Emergency Gift Service!”

Back in 2000, while everybody else was barreling down to their fortified basements, readying to defend their stockpiles of distilled water and fruit jerky, we optimistically decided to open an unconventional little gift store that sold jewelry, housewares, and anything else that tickled our fancy. Happily, that whole apocalypse thing blew over pretty quickly. But we’re still here, humbly accepting “Best Gift Shop In Indianapolis” awards on the regular, and relentlessly seeking out new offerings for you to present on every birthday, holiday, and—what the hey—Thursday.

Reviewed by
Jennifer R.

April 22, 2024

I know....another gift store review. I just can't help myself. This is one of the great ones. It checks off all of the boxes: Cool, fun, unusual items - check! Friendly helpful staff -... Read more

Reviewed by
Madison C.

February 25, 2024

Love shopping here! Great spot to buy gifts for others or for yourself:-) Employees are always friendly & helpful. One of my frequent stops on the weekends!! Read more

Reviewed by
Amanda L.

June 02, 2023

I've had Silver in the City bookmarked on my maps since the last time I was in Indy several years ago as a spot I wanted to check out. I wasn't able to check it out when I was here last, so when I... Read more

View 221 reviews on