McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe

1624 W 38th St, Erie, Pennsylvania 16508 USA

62 Reviews

View Photos

Reasonable

Closed Now

Opens Thu 11a

Independent
Credit Cards
Accepted
Wheelchair
Accessible
No Wifi

Learn more about this business on Yelp.

“best neighborhood restaurant”

We are the 5 time Erie Times News People's Choice award winner for Best Neighborhood restaurant. We have been serving Erie for over 30 years.

Reviewed by
Edward K.

April 09, 2024

Overall, it was a great experience. . Pros- Service was friendly, knowledgeable, helpful, and pleasant. 100% happy with our server. Awesome menu variety. Very nice food portions. Loved the... Read more

Reviewed by
Colleen L.

April 08, 2024

There is a reason they are voted best Reuben in Erie. They never disappoint. Tried fried fish and a steak salad this time- fish batter was still soggy, ew, and one of the salad tomatoes was... Read more

Reviewed by
Emily K.

January 27, 2024

For the longest time I would always order a reuben here because they are so well known for it and it's amazing. Recently, I decided to try something new. And oh my gosh, I have been missing out on... Read more

View 62 reviews on