2 votes

Oyster Bay Bar

626 Main Street, Deadwood, South Dakota 57732 USA

Independent

“World-famous casino and restaurant!”

World Famous Oyster Bar and Italian Restaurant. As seen on Ghost Lab, HBO, the History Channel, Discovery Channel, and Travel Channel - the world famous Oyster Bay Bar. Casino and Italian seafood restaurant that also includes pasta and burgers, now featuring a Japanese Sushi Kiosk.

Add Review

Thanks!

Your Rating

Reviewed by
Kathleen Oanes

103 Reviews
80 Helpful

August 28, 2014

Rated 3.0

Having heard all the buzz about this restaurant, my boyfriend and I decided to give it a try. It was just so sad that we were expecting so much from it. Well, the staff were friendly, approachable and warm to their customers, which was really nice. But the food was just overrated. They were not appetizing at all. We had the smoked oysters and the captain's platter. The seafood was plain and bland. It also has this taste like it has been just frozen for so long. The place in itself was untidy, too. Wouldn't recommend eating here.

1 person found this review helpful

Reviewed by
John Russo-Zirkel

31 Reviews
19 Helpful

September 15, 2015

Rated 5.0

Oyster Bay is an awesome bar. If you're looking for somewhere flashy and fancy this isn't your place, but if you're looking for an authentic vibe, the best oyster shooters in the world, and even a haunted tour be sure to check this place out!

Was this helpful?

Be the first to add a review to the Oyster Bay Bar.