My family has been to Williamsburg twice now and we plan to go again in the future. If you love history (or even if you don't) this is an amazing place to visit. The staff is so knowledgable and the historical interpreters/reenactors will take you back to colonial times. Last time we visited I learned about furniture making, listened to the Marquis de Lafayette speak for America's freedom and even had a conversation with a brilliant man of the law - Mr. Patrick Henry - at the local coffee house.
There is seemingly an endless amount of things to look at and people to talk to. It's a great vacation area for families - with Jamestown, Yorktown, Busch Gardens and a water park in the immediate area, there is a lot to do in Williamsburg.
My wife and I ate here while driving home from vacation and we thought it was a little disappointing. Our server forgot some things and we had to ask for them (straws, side dishes, salad). The atmosphere was ok, though a little dusty imo (I'm probably more particular here; but I notice when lamps or walls haven't been dusted in a week or two). Food was mediocre (especially for the price). They looked fairly busy, so maybe it was just a fluke in our case, but I would've chosen to dine elsewhere if I had to choose again.
My wife and I live in Metamora and we love going here for breakfast. Both our folks live around the area as well and I know they'd agree. The price is really reasonable. The staff are seriously the friendliest servers ever; and super fast service - wow! It's a small country diner, but it's a community gem.